DBS to test Indonesian openness with RM21b takeover
UPDATED @ 08:50:23 PM 02-04-2012
SINGAPORE, April 2 — Singapore's DBS Group , Southeast Asia's biggest bank, is to buy Indonesia's Bank Danamon for $7.24 billion (RM21.7 billion), in a deal that could stir nationalist opposition stoked by anxious local rivals.
DBS, part-owned by Singapore sovereign investment arm Temasek Holdings, said on today it agreed to take over Danamon in a cash-and-shares transaction that would rank as Asia's fourth-largest banking deal.
Temasek is on both sides of the transaction as it also owns 67.4 per cent of Danamon, and has had additional exposure to Indonesia through the DBS franchise there.
If the deal is approved, Temasek will be invested in a single bank in Indonesia, rather than two – something that should please government officials in Jakarta, sources familiar with the deal said.
But Indonesia's biggest foreign takeover could become a test of its openness to overseas capital, a month after Jakarta moved to curb foreign ownership of mines and less than a year since it voiced concerns over foreign bank holdings.
It could also trigger more foreign bank takeovers, with shares in Bank Panin Indonesia jumping 6 per cent today on bets that it, too, could become a target.
However, some Indonesian bankers said they would try to block the deal and were considering a media campaign targetting public opinion in the hope of influencing politicians. Local rivals face stiffer competition from expanding foreign banks.
“You're going to see some movements to halt this deal in the coming days,” said a senior executive of a rival local bank, who asked not to be named because of what he called the sensitivity of the issue.
“This is about nationalism. We don't have to be afraid of Singapore ... We're going to raise this case to parliament, the central bank and (banking regulator) Bapepam,” he added.
Bankers and industry analysts agreed there was little scope for a rejection of the deal on strict regulatory grounds, but a politically focused campaign could prove unpredictable.
DBS is buying most of Danamon, at a hefty 52 per cent premium, in the form of new DBS shares from Temasek, which in turn will become an even bigger owner of DBS.
It would make Singapore-based DBS the fifth-biggest lender in Indonesia, one of southeast Asia's hottest markets, where bank penetration is low and annual loan growth runs at 20 per cent.
However, Danamon has lower returns on equity than some peers and a heavy exposure to auto financing, an area vulnerable to recently announced steps by policymakers to curb excessive lending in the region's largest economy.
“We have the capacity to unshackle these businesses,” DBS's CEO Piyush Gupta said in Jakarta today, briefing investors on his first major deal since becoming boss in 2009.
“This changes our growth profile,” Gupta said, adding the move would triple DBS's exposure to high-growth markets from 11 per cent now. The price was fair, he said, and the Indonesian growth story was reflected in Danamon not being a “cheap deal”.
Gupta said DBS would cut Danamon's funding costs, expand its business into regional trade and corporate finance – and break the perception of DBS as a low-margin, mature-market bank.
The price – S$6.2 billion (RM14.8 billion) in shares for Temasek and the rest in cash for minority investors – initially surprised some investors, with the offering at 7,000 rupiah (RM2.30) per Danamon share, which last traded at 4,600 rupiah.
“Danamon minorities are in for a windfall,” said Anand Pathmakanthan, an analyst at Nomura Securities in Singapore, predicting DBS shares would suffer as a result.
But the price looked less generous using another valuation yardstick: at 2.6 times book value, it was below some other big banking takeovers in Indonesia – although previous benchmarks were set before the 2008-09 global financial crisis.
Temasek already owns about 29 per cent of DBS and its stake would rise to about 40 per cent after the deal. Temasek has obtained a regulatory waiver from having to make a general offer for the remaining DBS shares.
Trade in DBS and Danamon shares was halted today, pending the announcement. Danamon stock has fallen by a quarter over the past 12 months, while the wider Indonesian market has gained ground. DBS has fallen 2 per cent over the same period.
Looking to expand in Malaysia
DBS signalled today it also aimed to expand in neighbouring Malaysia, saying it had approval to negotiate to buy a 14 per cent interest in Alliance Financial Group – again from Temasek.
The Alliance stake is worth about $270 million. Shares in the Malaysian bank jumped 3 per cent on the news.
Gupta said Danamon suffered from high funding costs due to its weaker deposit base and use of wholesale markets, where interest rates had jumped since the global crisis.
According to its website, Danamon and its subsidiaries operate some 2,900 branches and points of sale, and employ close to 62,000 staff and non-permanent workers. Net income last year rose 16 per cent to 3.3 trillion rupiah (RM1.1 billion).
Gupta, 52, aims to expand DBS beyond Singapore and Hong Kong, which make the bulk of its profits, but one DBS shareholder, Aberdeen Asset Management, questioned whether Jakarta would have any concerns over the Danamon deal.
“It will be interesting to see the reaction of Indonesian authorities,” said Hugh Young, Aberdeen's Asia chief.
Indonesia's central bank last year considered a law to limit bank ownership, putting some deals on ice, but the state deposit agency recently said policymakers would not go ahead with it.
Some bankers said Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd would also be watching the Danamon takeover closely. ANZ, which owns 38.5 per cent of Bank Panin, is keen to increase its stake, but valuation differences derailed talks with the founding Gunawan family, which holds 46 per cent.
Gupta said he expected the Danamon deal to close in the second half of the year, subject to regulatory approval.
The deal's implied price-to-book ratio of 2.6 times is below the 4.2 times paid by HSBC for Indonesia's Bank Ekomomi Raharaja in 2008. It is also below the multiple paid by Maybank for Bank Indonesia Internasional.
Credit Suisse and Morgan Stanley are joint financial advisers to DBS, while WongPartnership LLP and Hadiputranto, Hadinoto & Partners are legal advisers.
Temasek is advised by Bank of America-Merrill Lynch and UBS. Danamon is advised by Citigroup and Deutsche Bank. — Reuters