US, Mexico reach tomato deal to avert trade war

Mexico exports about RM6 billion worth of tomatoes to the United States each year. – Reuters picMexico exports about RM6 billion worth of tomatoes to the United States each year. – Reuters picMEXICO CITY, Feb 3 – The US government and Mexican tomato growers reached a tentative agreement yesterday that reduces the threat of a costly trade war stemming from a US decision last year to pull out of a 1996 bilateral tomato trade pact.

“I am pleased that we were able to come to an agreement on fresh tomato imports from Mexico that restores stability and confidence to the US tomato market and meets the requirements of US law,” US Commerce Under Secretary for International Trade Francisco Sanchez said in a statement.

The draft agreement substantially raises the minimum “reference” price at which Mexican plum, cherry and other tomatoes can be sold in the United States and accounts for changes that have occurred in the tomato market since the original agreement, Sanchez said.

For some Mexican tomatoes, the new reference price is more than double the current such price, Sanchez said. The deal is expected to take effect on March 4, after a public comment period, he said.

Mexican Economy Minister Ildefonso Guajardo said the deal guaranteed Mexican farmers access to the US market under conditions that were “fair and competitive.”

“We worked hand in hand with Mexican producers on this agreement to avoid damage to the sector,” he said.

The US Commerce Department made a preliminary decision in September to terminate the 1996 tomato agreement after Florida growers complained that the arrangement no longer protected them against Mexican tomatoes sold below the cost of production.

That angered Mexican growers, who argued the pact had benefited US consumers and brought stability to the North American market.

Mexican officials said the US move appeared designed to help President Barack Obama carry Florida in his election battle against Republican Mitt Romney. Obama won the state in the November contest.

Mexico exports about US$1.9 billion (RM6 billion) worth of tomatoes to the United States each year. Varieties include common round, cherry, grape, plum, greenhouse and pear tomatoes. The industry says Florida producers have not kept pace with new growing techniques that produce tastier tomatoes and have propelled Mexican sales.


The proposed agreement spares Mexican growers from having to wage a costly legal battle against a new anti-dumping case brought by Florida producers.

It also averts the possibility of a broader trade war. US business groups such as the US Chamber of Commerce feared Mexico could retaliate if the United States slapped hefty duties on Mexican tomatoes.

Reggie Brown, executive vice president of the Florida Tomato Exchange, stopped short of endorsing the agreement but said it vindicated the US industry’s position that Mexican growers were “dumping” their tomatoes in the United States.

“Mexican growers and their government have tried to protect their interests with tremendous pressure on our government, threats to US producers and a well-funded lobbying and media campaign,” Brown said.

“The facts, however, were clear and could not be disputed. Mexican tomatoes were being sold in the US market in rapidly increasing volumes at prices that did not reflect the cost of production,” he said.

The new pact sets reference prices for four categories of tomatoes, instead of just one under the current pact. It also broadens coverage to include essentially all Mexican growers and exporters, the Commerce Department said.

The four categories, from least to most expensive, are “open field and adapted environment” tomatoes, “controlled environment” tomatoes, “specialty loose” tomatoes and “specialty packed” tomatoes.

The agreement sets winter and summer references prices for each category. The winter prices range from 31 cents per pound for open field and adapted environment tomatoes to 59 cents for specialty packed. The summer prices range from 24.6 cents to 46.8 cents per pound.

The single reference price for all Mexican tomatoes under the current agreement is 21.6 cents per pound in the winter and 17.2 cents in the summer. – Reuters


Please refrain from nicknames or comments of a racist, sexist, personal, vulgar or derogatory nature, or you may risk being blocked from commenting in our website. We encourage commenters to use their real names as their username. As comments are moderated, they may not appear immediately or even on the same day you posted them. We also reserve the right to delete off-topic comments