KUALA LUMPUR, Jan 27 – A second autopsy on suspected car thief Kugan Ananthan has found external injuries caused by blunt force trauma, sources told The Malaysian Insider.
The 22-year-old, who died while in police custody on Jan 20, was said to have died of cardiac arrest following the injuries, the sources said.
Initial findings also revealed Kugan was asthmatic, and his condition had caused phlegm to accumulate in his lungs.
The full report is expected to be issued within days after Universiti Malaya Medical Centre pathologists carried out the autopsy that lasted nearly 10 hours on Sunday following a dispute over earlier findings that he had died of "water in the lungs".
The Attorney-General’s Chambers have classified the case as murder and 11 policemen from the Subang USJ Taipan police station have been reassigned to desk duty pending investigations.
It is understood that closed-circuit-television-cameras (CCTV) were not placed in the police station’s lock-up despite a directive years ago that was intended to prevent claims of police abuse.
Kugan was said to be part of a syndicate involved in stealing luxury cars but his family said he has no criminal record and worked as an insurance claims executive.
Kugan will be cremated at the Puchong Batu 14 crematorium on Wednesday.
Fearing trouble, police have warned his family and friends not to turn the funeral into a protest following unconfirmed reports that a procession with banners and placards are being planned.
The police are now questioning some 21 people, including two deputy ministers, for allegedly barging into a hospital mortuary to view Kugan’s body last week. The family and the two politicians dispute the police and hospital version of events, saying they had a right to see the body.
His death is the latest over the years of suspects, mainly Indians, who had died suddenly in police custody.
Political parties across the divide have asked for an independent probe into his death and others in the past.
His family has also criticised the police for hiding behind a wall of silence over the death.
“The police never informed us that he was arrested and we only heard about it from an anonymous caller,” Kugan’s uncle V. Raviroy told The Malaysian Insider.
The 42-year-old businessman said no matter what Kugan was accused of doing; he did not deserve to die.
“Kugan was only 22, he had his whole life ahead of him, why did he end up dead in the lockup?” he lamented.

written by Careful, January 27, 2009
written by judge, January 27, 2009
So if the finding has shown the brutual assualt, any criminal being charged and bring to justice?
Or the police is still above the law with license to kill.
Full of shame our PDRM, especially the CPO of Selangor and the IGP.
written by hope for all, January 27, 2009
"Or is the PDRM afraid to own up for what they did?"
written by Obvious, January 27, 2009
written by deja vu, January 27, 2009
"closed-circuit-television-cameras (CCTV) were not placed in the police station’s lock-up despite a directive years ago"... aha! gotcha! alright, can someone please make sure all the police stations adhere to this THIS time around? jangan tunggu sampai something happen lah!!!
"Kugan was said to be part of a syndicate involved in stealing luxury cars but his family said he has no criminal record and worked as an insurance claims executive" ... er, even someone without a criminal record and worked as an insurance claims executive CAN commit crime, so please don't come out with something so childish.
“The police never informed us that he was arrested and we only heard about it from an anonymous caller” ... malu lah PDRM (perhaps the Raja-raja council is vying for 'DR' to be dropped from 'PDRM')
"Is it any different when Malaysians protested by burning effigy and flags when the faraway and unfortunate Palestinians killed by Israeli forces?" ... itu boleh, ini tak boleh. kenapa? PDRM: don't ask lah!
written by Abraham, January 27, 2009
written by Ken, January 27, 2009
"The CCTV were not placed in the Police Station"? Or is it more like the PDRM didnt like what the CCTV showed, and terefore they removed it and claimed that it was never installed, hence all the evidence of the brutal murder of Kugan is no longer available.
Malaysia is going to the dogs, and the PDRM are the main culprits in making this happen. I am so ashamed to call myself Malaysian now. Too bad we cant do anything about this
written by candidman, January 27, 2009
written by willy, January 27, 2009
written by Sorry State, January 27, 2009
1. Blocking access to the facts of the case . Charge the CPO Selangor.
2.Criminal Intimidation - Charge CPO Selangor and Home Minister.
written by focussed08, January 27, 2009
The family members were right to barge in to gain access to the body to ensure that there is no cover up.
If the police had its way, this whole episode of police brutality would never have surfaced for public information and dissemination. A different version of cause of death had already been determined to cover up the criminal acts by the relevant authorities.
I hate to think of all the previous death in custody cases where the reasons given by the examining doctors were compromised (as was the case with Kugan) in collusion with PDRM!!
When authorities failed to uphold truth and honesty for the betterment of the people and seek to cover up or collude with others to prevent the truth from surfacing, they are commiting a criminal offence and as such, are not deserving to be protectors of our rule of law in this country.
When trust has been so blatantly abused, the family of Kugan has every reason/rights to do what they had done to ensure justice had been done....and in this case, to ensure that the culprits are brought to justice! If the protectors of our law and order had a history of acting professionally, there would never have been any necessity for such an event to have occured.
written by Lek, January 27, 2009
1. replace bn with pkr
2. replace ag
3. replace igp
4. replace selangor cpo
5. replace pdrm
6. replace all umno judges
7. replace cheif justuce
8. replace etc etc etc too long a list
written by shankar, January 27, 2009
written by yc, January 27, 2009
Let the nation remember him
He was arrested
He was beaten,
He was brutalised
His life was cut short by PDRM
He will be remembered not for his sin
But for the brutality inflicted him.
written by Kopi O Kau, January 27, 2009
written by scrutinizer, January 27, 2009
2) (CCTV) were not placed in the police station’s lock-up despite a directive years ago that was intended to prevent claims of police abuse. The police head in USJ Taipan should be sacked immediately for not following orders and failed severely in police competency.
3) Selangor IGP should be suspended for overly protecting & cover police irregularities and stop making statements creating further social unrest.
4) The police immediate focus should be on the investigation on the 11 police suspects to ascertain the murderers and NOT on the questioning of 21 people, including two deputy ministers, for allegedly barging into a hospital mortuary. What has this to do with solving the mysterious death?
Ask BN & Syed Hamid, where is the police priority??
written by bigone, January 27, 2009
written by Chauncey Gardener, January 27, 2009
written by carboncopy, January 27, 2009
Its cover up is tantamount to tampering with evidence.
Tempering with evidence in a murder case carries death sentence.
So who did the first autopsy?
written by Lek, January 27, 2009
written by shankar, January 27, 2009
written by mikecheong, January 27, 2009
See. The above is "basically" the same results as the 1st post mortem, only difference is the words "water in the lungs" and "phlegm to accumulate in his lungs". So, the expatriate pathologist gets to keep his job while the perpetrators go scot free.
The Attorney-General’s Chambers have classified the case as murder.
What murder?? Taking the report at face value, I see that the results as reported so far has got nothing to link it with murder. The AG is such a smart fellow, classifying the case as murder and knowing very well the murder charge will not stick!!
this country needs a complete overhaul
Well said, Lek.
written by Don, January 27, 2009
syed hamid is the biggest dumb f**k i've seen.. Making a big issue about the family storming in the hospital.. Their son has died due to the countries messed up police force filled with corruption and bribery, instead of finding for the rotten egg in the force, you make the hospital a big issue? So childish,stupid and brainless, I'm only 18 but if a dumb big old man like you can't look at the big picture, then you should be working in the paddy fields or tapping rubber in the estates. God knows how dumb morons like you manage to become politicians.
written by bigone, January 27, 2009
The pathologist's report is not out yet.
Which part of "preliminary" don't you understand?
Which part of "was said to have died of cardiac arrest following the injuries, the sources said" do you also not understand? That alone is enough to suggest murder.
And the first doctor has been partially vindicated. Kugan did have fluid in his lungs. Whether that fluid was the cause of death is another matter, which will become clear when the full report comes out.
Conclusion is a quicksand pit for those who jump too quickly ...
Such is the state of Malaysia's education system, sigh.
written by faith04, January 27, 2009
written by youtstruly, January 27, 2009
written by Lek, January 27, 2009
written by bigone, January 27, 2009
There is no published record of the family calling Khalid a liar on the point below, about asthma.
Man dies during police interrogation
"Khalid said family members of the suspect had informed police that he was suffering from asthma. "
http://www.themalaysianinsider.com/index.php/malaysia/16396-man-dies-during-police-interrogation
written by Suresh, January 27, 2009
So, if the hospital authority's claim is untrue, go ahead and sue them. That way they can put the record straight.
written by Bat, January 27, 2009
written by sg, January 27, 2009
written by Penyokong PAS Cina., January 27, 2009
written by casey, January 27, 2009
Everything is OK. We maintain law and order to protect the rakyat. We keep people under police custody and ISA to protect them and for their personal safety. Trust me. Trust us. Those who allegedly barged into the hospital mortuary will be punished. Period.
written by Do the Right Thing, January 27, 2009
Or is that PDRM is sure that with Kugans death there will be no more theft of luxury cars?
written by longkanghead, January 27, 2009
written by Rahman, January 27, 2009
justice for him.
written by :: a different drummer ::, January 28, 2009
Malaysians,
I have seen the bad side and the good side of our man in uniforms. I have seen them act chivalrously and I have seem them taken bribes before my eyes. Suffice to say, there are devils and there are, also, angels among them. As so are we when dealing with our everyday lives. At times we grab opportunities which are ethically questionable and in under different circumstances we will not do it.
The point of the matter, is not to go overboard with our bashing of the man in uniform. They may be our uncles, our aunties, our brothers, our sisters, etc. We can be angry at these atrocity but we have to act with civility and not be coerced into demonising our brothers in uniforms.
The crux of the matter is, there is a more crucial reform that Malaysians have to do at our social structure. We are quick to blame others for our travesty and woes, we do not want to be accountable for our own misbehaviour and mischief. When we are faced with injustices affecting our financial, physical and mental well-being, we turn to people of the uniform.
Therefore, our bashing of police and other uniform bodies must be toned down. We have to act intelligently and civilly. Malaysian of tomorrow needs to be a civil society which holds dearly the rule of laws, albeit Hudud Law or Civil Law, and are accountable to their actions or inaction.
written by Andrew, January 28, 2009
written by justice denied, January 28, 2009
written by confused?!, January 28, 2009
written by bigone, January 27, 2009
I hate it too when we jump into conclusion too soon, however, IT IS NOT TOO SOON AS SOON AS SOMEONE ANSWER THE FOLLOWING QUESTION - WHERE IN THE WORLD ARE THE CCTVs??!!!!
Why wasn't there any CCTV when there should be one in the first place?
Do you remember the Miranda Law? You have the right to remain silent? Say supposing the police arrested someone but did not read his/her rights, can the case still stand? OR what about police barging into a premise without any warrant. Will the case still stand?
Now coming back to the current case, there should be CCTVs stationed but no CCTV found, will the case still stand? What's there to argue about? 1ST AUTOPSY? 2nd Autopsy? 3rd autopsy? WHERE ARE THE CCTVS?? Come to think about it, there should be CCTV too in the autopsy room to make sure things are done by the book!





Is it any different when Malaysians protested by burning effigy and flags when the faraway and unfortunate Palestinians killed by Israeli forces? Or is the PDRM award to own up what they did?