IPOH, Feb 8 – To political analyst Prof Datuk Dr Shamsul Amri Baharuddin, the political situation in Perak raises questions whether the Malays, especially Pas supporters, had been used to champion the interests of the majority DAP and the minority Pas and Parti Keadilan Rakyat in defending the state government.
Unlike the Pakatan Rakyat (PR)’s earlier united actions of trying to get the Internal Security Act (ISA) abolished and calling for clean elections, he said the action of going against the establishment of a Barisan Nasional (BN) government in Perak showed “some discord among the PR component parties”.
What is clear is that the demonstration last Friday to oppose the appointment of BN’s Dr Zambry Abdul Kadir as Menteri Besar at Masjid Ubudiah, about 300m from Istana Iskandariah in Kuala Kangsar, was made up of Pas supporters without the participation of PR supporters of other races.
“Do these voices represent the interests of the DAP majority or the Malay minority? If we look at the demonstration that day it raise questions of whether Malays had been used as the BN also has a Malay majority,” Dr Shamsul told Bernama today.
What is more sad, he opined, is the show of feelings as if the Malays were ready to censure the institution of the rulers held in such high esteem in this country though their words and hand signs besides blocking the vehicle of the Regent of Perak, Raja Dr Nazrin Shah.
The incident goes clearly against the the Rukun Negara principle of “Loyalty to King and Country” and where the institution of the rulers embraces all races and religions in the country.
“Such emotional sentiments are out of control as the Pakatan Rakyat still questions how they were defeated. Now there is an political and constitutional impasse,” said kata Shamsul Amri.
He also questioned why other races did not oppose the forming of the BN government when the PR state government claimed to represent all races.
The issue of whether Pas had been played out by its allies in the PR has also been discussed in cyberspace with various arguements that DAP’s 17 state assembly seats were more dominant then Pas’ and PKR’s six and five seats respectively.
Political analyst Prof Dr Azahari Ismail said the actions of the PR should reflect its make up in defending its government.
“Let not in one ugly demonstration only side is passionate and others are not bothered and do nothing,” said Azahari.
He said the political structure in the country had been divided at the federal, state and district levels and any support or opposition must reflect that position.
“If the matter is reasonable, the relevant people should at the forefront, not those unaffected,” said Azahari referring to the demonstration last Friday that appeared to be attended by PR supporters from outside Perak.
About 50 DAP supporters held a peaceful demonstration outside the Perak state secretariat building today, five days after the PR state government fell into the hands of the BN.
Meanwhile, Pas’ vanguard corps, known as the “red ants army” was still guarding the official residence of the Perak Menteri Besar which is still being occupied by Datuk Seri Mohammad Nizar Jamaluddin who has been told by the Sultan of Perak to relinquish his post.
Mohamad Nizar had told the media that the PR state government would not step down until the High Court rules that it should. – Bernama

written by zik, February 08, 2009
If you guys think it's not true..so proof it to this numskull!!
written by Kopi O kau, February 08, 2009
written by Singha, February 08, 2009
written by felix, February 08, 2009
written by Malaysian, February 08, 2009
written by bigone, February 08, 2009
Anyone care to guess what would happen if non-Malays criticise royalty? Anyone?
The professor is an Umno stooge (how else can he get a degree, much less an academic title?) who is trying to drive a wedge among the anti-BN forces. DON'T take the bait.
This is a fight that only Malays can fight. The rest can support wholeheartedly at the polling booth.
written by susan, February 08, 2009
written by Tonberry, February 08, 2009
The chinese dont vent their anger through demos. They prefer the ballot box. Remember all MCA/gerakan got booted out from Penang. yes. 100% booted out. None left. In Perak, only 1 MCA ADUN is left. So u see, different races have different culture of protesting.
written by Great Alibaba, February 08, 2009
This sub-standard analyst is still having his pea-brain and myopic mind shackled in the cocoon of racism. To fight against injustice is universal human value. It doesn't matter whether you are black, white, yellow, brown , red or others.
When you see the basic right of a people being abused, normal human being will support the victim and fight against the injustice.
When you see a democartically elected MB being chased out of his office WITHOUT THE DUE PROCESS, you will give him your hand.
So Mr. Professor, what are you talking about ?
As an so-called analyst or professor, the last thing you should do is to pull the wool of racism over peoples' eyes .
Besides showcasing your irresponbilities, it is immoral too.
written by cty, February 08, 2009
written by TadaAkal, February 08, 2009
Pada malam Khamis, Rakyat berbilang bangsa hadir di kediaman MB Perak memberi sokongan.
Sembahyang Jumaat kat masjid kat istana mestilah Melayu Islam, jangan lah perbodohkan Melayu!!!
written by natio, February 08, 2009
Chinese held protest outside MCA's organised Chinese New Year function which Najib suppose to attend proved just that. Chinese are very pantang of mentioning death, graveyard and etc during Chinese New Year, however the setting up of make ship tombstone and graveyard to protest shows how angry Chinese people in Perak toward the political event in Perak.
People don't be fool by BN's lies.
written by Kenny Gan, February 08, 2009
To say that the demo at Kuala Kangsar was an act by PAS alone is deceitful. Yes, Malays were the majority among the demonstrators but that was probably a reflection of the racial composition of the town. Police had blocked the roads going to Kuala Kangsar from Ipoh. It was after prayers at a mosque for goodness sake. Don't ignore the non-Malays there although in the minority.
How did this Shamsul infer that the Malays there were from PAS? Did they have white moons on their foreheads? Can't ordinary Malays protest against injustice irrespective of any political affiliation?
MalaysianInsider should not accept such biased articles with racial overtones and ulterior motives seeking to create racial and political tension by authors who are nothing more than paid Umno stooges.
written by Asam Pedas, February 08, 2009
DAP despite being majority allowed Nizar to be the MB. Isn't this speaks volume ?
This professor is really stupid.
written by OTBB, February 08, 2009
written by AP, February 08, 2009
written by Ehoe, February 08, 2009
This professor must be a well paid BN political analyst, otherwise he wouldn't be trying to steer- up ill feelings in the Malay rakyat towards other races by this comment.
For your information professor, it is not that we the non- Malay rakyat is not bother with the latest development in Perak. On the contrary, we are very pissed and are fuming inside. Many non- Malay rakyat would like to C4 that Madame prostitute Hee if they could lay their hand on some.
One of the reason we non- Malay are not demonstrating with our Malay brothers is because we do not wish to give the BN party anymore ammunition to play the racial card which they including you are very good in.
But come any by- election or the next general election for that matter then you and your BN partners will see the anger in the non-Malay rakyat.
written by Charles, February 08, 2009
The other 2 State Assemblymen who are waiting for the criminal charges against them to be heard in court also defected and supported a more powerful federal party, hoping that the criminal charges against them will either be dropped or lessen or even found not guilty eventually. As such, to resolve the uncertainties and disputes, I believe having a by election for these three constituencies is the most appropriate. As a loyal citizen, I really hope that the current situation is brought under control by having the problem resolved. I wonder who will take the blame or be responsible when the rakyat begin to lose their patience. When hell break loose, the rakyat will go for each other, instead of to the polls.
written by Kopitiam Chat, February 08, 2009
written by Suresh, February 08, 2009
Go to Hell with Berrnama.
written by abdulmanja, February 08, 2009
I never had much respect for these so-called lecturers from the Arts stream. They are full of emotion which they cover up, using high-sounding jargon.
written by Charles, February 08, 2009
written by KG, February 08, 2009
written by Tidur, February 08, 2009
especially those Raja Hitam will rule darurat
this is how the idiot professor never study this topic. Racist
written by subramaniam, February 08, 2009
written by focussed08, February 08, 2009
FYI (just in case you don't know what it stands for, it's "for your information"), the person who is directly and critically affected is Datuk Nizar and he is a PAS member.
As a professor with the calling of a political analyst, you presumed that you understood the notion of equal representation in every situations. Unfortunately, as with every such "highly qualified" (..a'hem!)limelight seekers, they tend to look and hunt for reasons where non exists. They try to go way beyond what is merely in front of them to try to explain something very apparent. They need to write or express a thesis or a book of intrigue in order that their calling could be appreciated.
In direct line of fire is Datuk Nizar and the fuel of this outburst of indignity is the fact that he was so unfairly and unceremoniously discarded by the authorities and the whole episode was illegal and high-handed. Anger is spontaneous and infectious, spreading like wildfires which tends to lingers on and tends to generate anxiety which leads to the need for expression resulting in outpouring of their feelings on that day.
Trying to link everything to anything is just trying to justify your wish to be acknowledged as knowledgeable in something where there is nothing!
And I don't even need to explain why other groups were not significantly involved because everyone else knows why.............er, except you.......of course, but, who cares?
written by Professor Gila, February 08, 2009
Makan nasi UMNO , cakap ikut taukeh ...poordah
written by antipode, February 08, 2009
Why should any news portal feel ashamed for publishing any article with source made clear for all to see?
Guess some malaysians prefer ignorance to hearing or reading opposing views.
written by Mr Smith, February 08, 2009
I suggest you enter UMNO since you speak like one of them. You are either a fake political analyst or a politician.
I have read your convoluted commentary many times.
written by Mohd Amin, February 08, 2009
written by DON/NS, February 08, 2009
written by Tonto, February 08, 2009
written by lonwolf, February 08, 2009
Check this out ...
http://thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2009/2/8/nation/20090208110837&sec=nation
Then see this photo..
http://mrsmith2.blogspot.com/2009/02/hee-yit-foong-you-sold-chinese-and-your.html
Thats is a very big insult a living person can take ...
Also check this from MalaysiaKini..
http://www.malaysiakini.com/news/97846
Though the number is small but the message is clear.
Democracy was killed by Barisan Najis..
I know the analyst may get some dirty money from BN for such a cheap article to cause disunity and racial problems.
written by vinnan, February 08, 2009
written by Jason, February 08, 2009
written by goldenscreen, February 08, 2009
We Chinese and Indians have our own way of showing our anger towards the illegal government. This numbskull professor should butt out of business which are none of his concern.
written by Ahmad, February 08, 2009
Bila tiada ada "KELUHURAN PERLEMBAGAAN", mana mungkin ada "KESETIAAN KEPADA RAJA".
written by PlainTruth, February 08, 2009
Perhaps, more importantly, in that short space of time, he has successfully dispelled the non-Malay fears of PAS.
These are facts regardless of the amount of spin that the BN generate in the news media that they control.
written by antipode, February 08, 2009
written by icky, February 08, 2009
written by haji md aris bin ismail, February 08, 2009
written by maaysian voter, February 08, 2009
written by ethan, February 08, 2009
written by Dalbinder Singh Gill, February 08, 2009
written by KKLim, February 08, 2009
Just to remind this UKM "prof " and "political analyst" if the chinese were so endearing to the BN, why was it that less than a year ago, all (less one) of the non Malay BN seats in Perak were wiped clean ? For his academic enlightenment - protest can be in many forms : public demonstrations is only one of the many methods, but it may not be the most lethal. That's why in a democracy, the ballot box is still the most gentle but also the most powerful tool. So for those who still subscribe to democratic principles, winning peoples' heart and minds is still the formula - not by bullying and scare tactics nor by deception and spin. The Malaysian rakyat today is not the same like yesteday. Their minds have been liberated by the net. Ignore this at your own peril. Hope u do some research on this before u express yr "intellectual" opinion.
written by Peter, February 08, 2009
Why must PR gorv., want to give an excuse to Amno for racial riot? They like to play the racial card all the time and that is why only Pas and PKR supporters are called to demonstrate and give no chance for Amno to use this card. I think you are totally wrong in saying that DAP did not take part and leaving it to PAS and PKR. Anwar is very wise to see through Amno scheme. He knows what he is doing . Whatever you say will not affect the strong bond for the coalition. The malays in PR knows what they are doing so you think that it will affect them to change to BN? Sorry and sorry again. It wont work.
written by Ramesh N P Chandran, February 08, 2009
written by Raymond Woo, February 08, 2009
Firstly, you might have forgotten that Perakians, and many Malaysians of ALL races oppose the illegitimate takeover of Perak by the BN. This is evident from the blogsphere and grassroots sentiment. However, if you insist on using demonstrations as the only litmus test for political expression, you have conveniently left out the "Chinese" demonstration against Zambry in Ipoh.
Secondly, the Kuala Kangsar incident was probably a case of emotions boiling over. The Malays who demonstrated had just returned from attending the Ubidiah mosque, and perhaps due to information exchange among like-minded Malays, they rioted, and I propose that they might have been provoked by the tear-gas throwing FRU. Obviously, this incident just after the Friday Muslim prayers could not have involved the other races.
So, you evil moron, don't try to stir up trouble and destroy Malaysia!!
written by Cool Head, February 09, 2009
The other "analyst" Prof Dr Azahari Ismail can be found at the Fakulti Penggajian Pendidikan, presumably contributing immensely to the education of students under his tender care. Anyone care to dig up his e-mail address or phone number for those interested to communicate withhim?
No doubt the the Bernama report is a piece of trash ... still , I will resist the itch to cast too much aspersion upon the analytical skills of our honourable profs .... it could just as well reflect sub-standard reporting and editing at Bernama instead ... wouldn't be too surprise!
Meanwhile let's NOT allow ourselves to be manipulated into turning this thing into a racial issue or to break the unity of PR. Enough of race-based and divisive politics. We don't need to be professors to be wiser than some so-called "Professors". All we really need is cool heads and common sense.
written by steven, February 09, 2009
They are just trying to split the Pakatan..
Also. as MB Nizar said, these demo were the people sentiments not organised by Pakatan..
written by Pewaris pah!, February 09, 2009
written by rahman, February 09, 2009
They will review as first-rate article.
written by Akam, February 09, 2009
written by Douglas, February 09, 2009
Action speaks louder than words... "Professor??" !!!
written by Jonas, February 09, 2009
Prinsip Rukun Negara
1. Kepercayaan kepada Tuhan
2. Kesetiaan kepada Raja dan Negara
3. Keluhuran Perlembagaan
4. Kedaulatan Undang-undang
5. Kesopanan dan Kesusilaan
If you don't believe in God thats up to you but if you think UMno is God, boy you're in trouble.
No. 2 is what you mentioned.
No. 3 shows that you're missing the whole point
No. 4 is almost non-existent when it comes to UMno and its cronies
No. 5 is what the rakyat loses when no. 3 and no. 4 is put aside
He opt's to exclude facts at convenience to prove a point that is blank. A Professor, Datuk and Dr., those titles doesn't do justice to the comments he makes as a political analyst. Speaking of justice... ah don't bother. It left Malaysia in 1981.
written by Muhd Iqbal, February 09, 2009
Professor ekonomi ni bila masa pula jadi penganalisa politik?
Buku ekonomi tak laku ke?
written by focussed08, February 09, 2009
You have to be pretty much a stooge to agree 100% with the opinion of another person! That's what stooges do - because they have no brains or don't know how to use them. Perhaps, now is about time that you need to put them into gear. Think of when the event occured and where. How it occured is simple and doesn't need a stooge to understand.
Now if you were to think more independently and carefully, it was a Friday and the situation developed from around the mosque after prayer which was just a stone's throw away from the target. As the march was a sponteneous event undertaken by those who just came out of the mosque, why on earth should there be any proportional representation of the races accordding to seats in such an event under such circumstances is well and truly beyond anyone's comprehension! Anyway, we do we need to think of any events in terms of race based?
There were no valid reasons why other races have to be there at that time because it was not a planned or organised event - it a was spontaneous event by a grieving group at the insults befallen upon one of their member, a PAS member.
Now, do you comprehend, STUPID?
Well, at least the brainless professor now has a 'tag-along' stooge to keep him company. Not much of a tag-team though. One talks 100% of the time about nothing and the other just thinks about nothing 100% of the time............................100% in agreement my foot - just plain stupid, thats all!
written by Rakyat Malaysia, February 09, 2009
Sorry for you Prof, your racial thinking, divide and control, are all too familiar and outdated :((
I think you have miss the keywords...now is for PEOPLE POWER & EMPOWERMENT
written by wof, February 09, 2009
Just wonder which university he got the professor tittle ? is it bought from back-door ?
written by IntegrityForAll, February 09, 2009
But the racist card is nothing new. Every single racial incident of racial tension in the history of Malaysia has been orchestrated by UMNO. This is a strategy which will not go away. Keep it up UMNO. God bless you





Ramai orang PAS kat KK itu kerana demo itu dibuat selepas sembahyang jumaat. DAP pulak buat demo kat tempat lain. yg dia pandai-pada buat teori bukan-bukan ni apasal?
Tak cukup nak bodohkan melayu lagi ke? suka bangsa awak bodoh supaya senang orang macam awak ni pijak
YOU ARE THE BIGGEST HYPOCRIT or dalam bahasa melayu - MUNAFIK
Firman Allah: apabila orang munafik menyampaikan perkhabaran kepada kamu, maka siasatlah dahulu perkhabaran tersebut