By Adib Zalkapli
PUTRAJAYA, July 8 — Realising that the administration could not afford to be criticised by Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad, the deputy prime minister today revealed that he had briefed the former prime minister on the decision to scrap the policy of teaching science and mathematics in English.
Tan Sri Muhyiddin Yassin who is also the education minister told a press conference today that he told Dr Mahathir that the spirit of the policy, better known as PPSMI, which is to improve English language proficiency, would be maintained.
“I was given the opportunity to give a briefing along with senior officers and the director-general at Tun’s residence, as a sign of respect for him who mooted the idea,” said Muhyiddin.
"We had a very long discussion, for more than three hours,” he added.
Muhyiddin said he explained to Dr Mahathir how the policy could not be implemented as intended.
Among the problems discussed, he said, was the huge gap between national schools and vernacular schools as well as teachers’ poor command of the English language.
“Me and my officers have clarified the progress and problems faced by those involved,” said Muhyiddin.
“Tun accepted our views,” he added.
Bookmark
Email This
Comments (38)
Show/Hide comments
...
written by alamalikut, July 08, 2009
written by alamalikut, July 08, 2009
What Tun Mahathir got to do with this stupid ideas???... weiiiii..Mahyuddin wake up.. kalau Tun M sudah keluar blah lah apa masuk campur lagi dlm kerajaan.... mengong punya statement.
-
- +2
-
-
...
written by Judge, July 08, 2009
written by Judge, July 08, 2009
Why Dr.M got to nod his head?
It is the rakyat should say yes or no, not the expiry ex-ex PM.
If he wants crook bridge, UMNO going to buy one for him?
It is the rakyat should say yes or no, not the expiry ex-ex PM.
If he wants crook bridge, UMNO going to buy one for him?
-
- +6
-
-
...
written by X-b.END, July 08, 2009
What is this...who's the Nation PM..Najib or DrM? I'm confused. Najib pls resigned...DrM wants his position back.
written by X-b.END, July 08, 2009
What is this...who's the Nation PM..Najib or DrM? I'm confused. Najib pls resigned...DrM wants his position back.
-
- +5
-
-
...
written by tohkong mosjid, July 08, 2009
written by tohkong mosjid, July 08, 2009
Tun just rebutted what you said lar Muhyiddin in his latest blog. You think he will let you spin out of this without some retaliation? Naive!
-
- +1
-
-
...
written by sapu, July 08, 2009
written by sapu, July 08, 2009
What a shame. TDM has to be briefed otherwise kena hentam. Malu lah. Anyway he accpeted but does not mean he's agreeable. Its the country's loss for reverting back to Bahasa for Maths and Sc. The spirit of the policy is FPFP........flip flop, flip flop.
-
- -1
-
-
...
written by Rayn, July 08, 2009
written by Rayn, July 08, 2009
Err..are you sure? That is not what Tun says in his blog... From what I understand Tun still favors Maths and Science be taught in English.
-
- +5
-
-
...
written by tan, July 08, 2009
written by tan, July 08, 2009
It is the right approach for betterment in the long run especially vision 2020.
-
- -2
-
-
...
written by ng boon tat, July 08, 2009
written by ng boon tat, July 08, 2009
absolutely..correct strategy..after all, we don't even know our grammar that well anyway...so, we should just keep the spirit alive (would be nice if your officers could explain what that means...)....brilliant, i must say..saves everyone the headaches and pain of needing to master yet another language..
“Me and my officers have....." what my teacher taught me a long time ago..would have made me use that sentence this way..." My officers and I have......"..but thanks for highlighting the fact the we Malaysians are really atrocious when it comes to english grammar, I have learned the proper use of english today...
so, i fully agree...we should scrap the english language altogether actually. we are not good at it anyway, and it puts us at such a severe disadvantage, especially when i am being compared to a singaporean, for example...if those foreign investors want to come to our country, they had better learn our national language..!!
“Me and my officers have....." what my teacher taught me a long time ago..would have made me use that sentence this way..." My officers and I have......"..but thanks for highlighting the fact the we Malaysians are really atrocious when it comes to english grammar, I have learned the proper use of english today...
so, i fully agree...we should scrap the english language altogether actually. we are not good at it anyway, and it puts us at such a severe disadvantage, especially when i am being compared to a singaporean, for example...if those foreign investors want to come to our country, they had better learn our national language..!!
-
- +2
-
-
...
written by Mohd Din, July 08, 2009
written by Mohd Din, July 08, 2009
How stupid can our DPM be? Apparently policies by the UMNO Goverment are guided NOT by whether they benefit the rakyat, but rather whether the old phat will criticise them or not.
How to progress ?
Malaysia Boleh!
How to progress ?
Malaysia Boleh!
-
- +3
-
-
...
written by Jamil Abdullah, July 08, 2009
written by Jamil Abdullah, July 08, 2009
Why have got to convince that senile bitter envious old man? Looks like DPM is eyeing Najib's post and hoping to get support from the said old guy.
-
- +0
-
-
...
written by Neo, July 08, 2009
written by Neo, July 08, 2009
Accepting what has been done doesn't mean agreeing on the decision made. Tun Dr.M has long been voicing his views to this matter in his blog. I dont think this article could soothe the public but this is really a fun reading.
-
- +2
-
-
...
written by dylan, July 08, 2009
written by dylan, July 08, 2009
what to convince??
Math don't bother english like this
SHE ARE A BOY.
Math don't bother english like this
SHE ARE A BOY.
-
- +0
-
-
...
written by OrangRojak, July 08, 2009
written by OrangRojak, July 08, 2009
Muhyiddin doesn't read Mahathir's blog then?
"my views ... are not reflected in the decision"
"my views ... are not reflected in the decision"
-
- +0
-
-
...
written by future, July 08, 2009
written by future, July 08, 2009
In UMNO tradition no one is responsible for the failure and nobody will apologize.Another few billions gone to the drain and of course into selected bank accounts.
-
- +2
-
-
...
written by leading, July 08, 2009
Tan Sri, you are right but in order for the nation NOT to be left behind, we still need to:
• • • Use English to teach Math and Science • • •
www.leading.com.my
written by leading, July 08, 2009
Tan Sri, you are right but in order for the nation NOT to be left behind, we still need to:
• • • Use English to teach Math and Science • • •
www.leading.com.my
-
- +0
-
-
...
written by Kana, July 08, 2009
written by Kana, July 08, 2009
Personally think this is a wrong move. With due respect, what will happen to our children if they go abroad to study or work.
Imagine you do not know how to explain a simple calculations in English.
Imagine you do not know how to explain a simple calculations in English.
-
- +1
-
-
...
written by dangermouse70, July 08, 2009
written by dangermouse70, July 08, 2009
ROTFLMAO!
" Me and my officers have clarified the progress......," said Muhyiddin.
Shouldn't that have been " My officers and I...."?
Now we know the real reason for scrapping this policy... even the daft have become more daft; that's why!
" Me and my officers have clarified the progress......," said Muhyiddin.
Shouldn't that have been " My officers and I...."?
Now we know the real reason for scrapping this policy... even the daft have become more daft; that's why!
-
- +7
-
-
...
written by ACR, July 08, 2009
written by ACR, July 08, 2009
TDM has been put on such a high pedestal he appears to be a demi-god in this country. Senior government servants running to his house to brief him on the change? Why?
Do you think Obama's administration would consult Bush if they change his policies? What a joke we have become.
The present government has the power to make policies and if it thinks what it is proposing is right and has the support of the people just implement it. Quit kow-towing.
Do you think Obama's administration would consult Bush if they change his policies? What a joke we have become.
The present government has the power to make policies and if it thinks what it is proposing is right and has the support of the people just implement it. Quit kow-towing.
-
- +1
-
-
...
written by wkc, July 08, 2009
written by wkc, July 08, 2009
DPM, how about trying to convince us first ? We are your masters, we pay all your salaries, perks, benefits, allowances through our taxes. NOT THE OLD TYRANT. The fact that you need to convince him shows two things - 1) the gravy train he initiated over the decades must have benefitted all of you so much that you all remain eternally grateful and 2) you have so little confidence in yourself that you can't withstand any little criticism and seek to pacify him first.
-
- +3
-
-
...
written by stupid and more stupid, July 08, 2009
written by stupid and more stupid, July 08, 2009
How come Tun Mahatir did not said he was convinced. Instead he said the opposite. So. Which version is correct?
-
- +1
-
-
...
written by sktan, July 08, 2009
written by sktan, July 08, 2009
Dr M claims his opinions on language switch ignored. Read here: http://www.themalaysianinsider...ch-ignored
So who is lying? Muhyiddin or Dr M? Someone should be fired for lying! Come on own up! Be a man!
So who is lying? Muhyiddin or Dr M? Someone should be fired for lying! Come on own up! Be a man!
-
- +4
-
-
...
written by Hang Tuah 1, July 08, 2009
Dr M claims his opinions on language switch ignored
By Adib Zalkapli
PUTRAJAYA, July 8 — Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad expressed disappointment with the government’s decision to scrap his policy of teaching mathematics and science in English, saying it will affect future generations.
He said his recommendations were not taken into consideration when deputy prime minister Tan Sri Muhyiddin Yassin, who is also Education Minister, met him over the policy first introduced in 2003.
“I was only briefed about it, so after the briefing I gave my suggestions, I said even if it could not be implemented at primary level, at least at secondary level it should be maintained, so it was not a consultation only briefing,” Dr Mahathir told reporters here.
“I am saddened because the future of our children will be affected. They will be the victims,” he added...
---
Ooops, Mr Muhyiddin -
Are you sure you have convinced Dr M on English policy????
Looks like Dr M disagrees with you.
Have you purposely misled the public???
written by Hang Tuah 1, July 08, 2009
Dr M claims his opinions on language switch ignored
By Adib Zalkapli
PUTRAJAYA, July 8 — Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad expressed disappointment with the government’s decision to scrap his policy of teaching mathematics and science in English, saying it will affect future generations.
He said his recommendations were not taken into consideration when deputy prime minister Tan Sri Muhyiddin Yassin, who is also Education Minister, met him over the policy first introduced in 2003.
“I was only briefed about it, so after the briefing I gave my suggestions, I said even if it could not be implemented at primary level, at least at secondary level it should be maintained, so it was not a consultation only briefing,” Dr Mahathir told reporters here.
“I am saddened because the future of our children will be affected. They will be the victims,” he added...
---
Ooops, Mr Muhyiddin -
Are you sure you have convinced Dr M on English policy????
Looks like Dr M disagrees with you.
Have you purposely misled the public???
-
- +6
-
-
...
written by manolito, July 08, 2009
written by manolito, July 08, 2009
Next time try convincing your REAL boss: the rakyat.
Ignore the old pensioner.
Ignore the old pensioner.
-
- +3
-
-
...
written by Kilo, July 08, 2009
written by Kilo, July 08, 2009
Whoa!..... Seems like this is going to be another classic "FLIP-FLOP" policy decision. How sad.
I can bet that the primary schools will revert but the secodary schools will stay on with English.
Think about it - my form 1 kid just took a full six years in English. Now they are going to switch to BM in form 4 and lo and behold - another switch to English in Form 6. Very obvious they are the guiness pigs at the expense of no-brain govt....
Lost faith in them long ago. Can't expect much from them.
I can bet that the primary schools will revert but the secodary schools will stay on with English.
Think about it - my form 1 kid just took a full six years in English. Now they are going to switch to BM in form 4 and lo and behold - another switch to English in Form 6. Very obvious they are the guiness pigs at the expense of no-brain govt....
Lost faith in them long ago. Can't expect much from them.
-
- +3
-
-
...
written by Silence Dogood, July 08, 2009
written by Silence Dogood, July 08, 2009
Oops.. Looks like Tun M is angry with someone. And you know what that means...
Run for cover Muhyiddin!!!!
Hell hath no fury for a mahafiraun scorned!
Alwiz thought you may tag-team with Tun to bring down Najib-Rosmah. Bad move Din!
Run for cover Muhyiddin!!!!
Hell hath no fury for a mahafiraun scorned!
Alwiz thought you may tag-team with Tun to bring down Najib-Rosmah. Bad move Din!
-
- +0
-
-
...
written by Jason, July 09, 2009
written by Jason, July 09, 2009
If Muhyiddin says he has convinced Dr M, then how come Dr M says he is disappointed with this decision? This is the classic Umno style. Making false claims and putting words into the horse's mouth.
-
- +3
-
-
...
written by Jong, July 09, 2009
written by Jong, July 09, 2009
Muhyiddin Yassin the lying Twister! He came out with a statement that Mahathir has been pacified and accepts the Cabinet's decision but the old jackal in his blog said otherwise. In the first place, why the need to please him, are they so afraid of him?
So now the truth is out, return of Mahathirism is here to stay which sadly, Najib has vehemently denied. They know they can't afford to be criticized by Mahathir least they meet the same fate as Mr Half-past-Six .
So now the truth is out, return of Mahathirism is here to stay which sadly, Najib has vehemently denied. They know they can't afford to be criticized by Mahathir least they meet the same fate as Mr Half-past-Six .
-
- +1
-
-
...
written by rini, July 09, 2009
written by rini, July 09, 2009
Dont cry for me Malaysia..Dont weep for me bangsa Melayu...The future children of the Malays will be further left behind all because the politicians want to be popular and the Malay language scholars want to be remembered and to be glorified.
Even the predominantly Malay/Indonesian speaking Indonesians are beginning to pick up English as the second most popular spoken language in order to be at par with the other advnacenations. yet Malaysia and especially the Malays are retreating into their cocoons.
Sorry Dr Mahathir..Dont cry for me Malaysia and dont weep for me Bangsa Melayu - you are digging your own grave.
Even the predominantly Malay/Indonesian speaking Indonesians are beginning to pick up English as the second most popular spoken language in order to be at par with the other advnacenations. yet Malaysia and especially the Malays are retreating into their cocoons.
Sorry Dr Mahathir..Dont cry for me Malaysia and dont weep for me Bangsa Melayu - you are digging your own grave.
-
- +3
-
-
...
written by Just me, July 09, 2009
written by Just me, July 09, 2009
My dear Mayudin,what type of language did you spoke to our old man during his advice, did you used English or BM?
I am sure you used English.In the middle of discussion this old man told you not to continue using (speaking)English used(speak)BM,Do not try to be smart ,You thought that he means not to cont.using English .Also you must have brought along your stupid sidekicks which don"t understand English,so go on ask him again,this time listen carefully used BM don't confuse yourself OK?
I am sure you used English.In the middle of discussion this old man told you not to continue using (speaking)English used(speak)BM,Do not try to be smart ,You thought that he means not to cont.using English .Also you must have brought along your stupid sidekicks which don"t understand English,so go on ask him again,this time listen carefully used BM don't confuse yourself OK?
-
- +0
-
-
...
written by Jong, July 09, 2009
written by Jong, July 09, 2009
YEAH. politicians and their foreign/English educated children are now guaranteed "heirs to rule" backward Malaysia. Malays in the 'ulus' just stay with Malay language, be experts on centuries old culture and show utmost loyalty to their 'state guardians' no matter what, just stay religious, better than buta huruf !!!
-
- +0
-
-
...
written by soon, July 09, 2009
written by soon, July 09, 2009
complete idiot. you are employed by the PEOPLE. you need to CONVINCE your EMPLOYERS which is the PEOPLE.
lets get rid of him. incompetent.
lets get rid of him. incompetent.
-
- +0
-
-
...
written by PH Chin, July 09, 2009
written by PH Chin, July 09, 2009
"We have convinced Dr M on English policy, says Muhyiddin"
Hahaha, what a joke or a lie ? Last night Tun Dr Mahathir lamented he was only briefed on the decision by the Minister and not consulted as claimed. I think our Minister cannot differentiate between briefing and convincing.
Hahaha, what a joke or a lie ? Last night Tun Dr Mahathir lamented he was only briefed on the decision by the Minister and not consulted as claimed. I think our Minister cannot differentiate between briefing and convincing.
-
- +1
-
-
...
written by betong, July 09, 2009
written by betong, July 09, 2009
Why Muhiddin need to convince Dr. Mahathir even he is nobody, not PM anymore?
Common reader, even u hate him very much but dont underestimate Mahathir. Mahathir influence is still very strong, he was excellent in term of removing 2 former primer, Tunku Abd Rahman and Pak Lah and most probably Tun Hussein.
So, that why gov must explain to him. If he disagree so he will start another round to remove Najib.
Ku Li says: Dr Mahathir adalah orang yang akan menyelesaikan apa yang beliau mulakan.
Common reader, even u hate him very much but dont underestimate Mahathir. Mahathir influence is still very strong, he was excellent in term of removing 2 former primer, Tunku Abd Rahman and Pak Lah and most probably Tun Hussein.
So, that why gov must explain to him. If he disagree so he will start another round to remove Najib.
Ku Li says: Dr Mahathir adalah orang yang akan menyelesaikan apa yang beliau mulakan.
-
- +0
-
-
Write comment
Show/Hide comment form
