KUALA LUMPUR, Dec 1 – The number of Malaysians who surrendered their citizenship has almost doubled in this year, according to Deputy Foreign Minister Senator A. Kohilan Pillay, who revealed today that about 3,800 Malaysians have given up their citizenships to date compared to 2,000 last year.
This figure, however, is much smaller than the 304,358 Malaysians who were reported to have migrated from March 2008 to August 2009.
Kohilan clarified that the number of “Malaysians who migrated” consists of those who are working abroad and registered with the respective Malaysian embassies.
There was nevertheless a sharp rise in the number of Malaysians who registered themselves as having moved abroad with 210,000 of them doing so from January to August this year compared with 94,000 from March to December 2008.
He also said that between 45 to 55 per cent, or roughly half, of the Malaysians working abroad are professionals.
The volume of Malaysian talent moving abroad is a potentially damaging brain drain and a matter of concern as the country is attempting to remake itself into a developed high-income nation.
The most common reasons given for migration were better education, brighter career or business prospects and marriage.
Kohilan also pointed out that the government is taking some steps to attract talent to the country, including making it easier for foreigners with desired expertise to obtain permanent residence.
Kohilan, who is from Gerakan, also criticised the Penang state government currently under Pakatan Rakyat, saying that they should stop using the shortage of engineers an excuse for the recent loss of an RM10 billion electronic factory investment and should instead find ways to overcome it.
“Penang should not blame others if there is no investment,” Kohilan told The Malaysian Insider. “What professionals would want to stay there if there is only push factors? There must also be pull factors. They must think wisely and make sure the state also has pull factors.”
Kohilan said that there was no breakdown by race for Malaysians who have moved abroad but some migration agents have noticed a rise in applications from Malays to migrate over the past few years.
Robert Chelliah, who runs a migration consultancy in Petaling Jaya says that he has seen a noticeable increase in interest among Malays to move to Australia.
“These are educated Malays and they feel frustrated with the system of governance and they have a global frame of reference to make comparisons,” he said.
“Generally, the push factor from Malaysia has been on the rise ... people feel pushed away from the country. They feel alienated and they feel that their prospects are limited by factors that they have no control over,” he added.
According to Kohilan, Australia had the most number of Malaysians registered with the Malaysian embassy with 274,000 and the US second with 31,000 and Taiwan third with 14,000.
He added that there were about 50,000 Malaysian students now studying abroad.

written by lek, December 01, 2009
written by lek, December 01, 2009
written by MatJais, December 01, 2009
written by benson, December 01, 2009
Yes, it is totally true
written by Andrewc, December 01, 2009
All those reading this article and have migrated, just add a simple comment to add to the numbers.
Andrew
written by rambo, December 01, 2009
Kohilan being part of BN is blind to the cause. The push factors are all out of the state hands like
corruption, high crime rate, poor education std, poor command of english, unethical and poor judicial
system
written by Rakan PR, December 01, 2009
written by ctlim, December 01, 2009
written by i_love_malaysia, December 01, 2009
written by Pan, December 01, 2009
all this talk of attracting talent to the country is plain stupid when perfectly good talent is leaving in droves while talent-in-country are taxed heavily and have low purchasing power with the weak ringgit.
fix the internal policy & processes to retain, not to acquire - it's more effective in terms of cost, efficiency and long term wealth creation.
show some true leadership for once la, stop mollycoddling those who cannot perform!
written by Kazakian, December 01, 2009
I think it's good you have come forward with the figures to show this problem. And I think it's good that the government actually acknowledges this as a problem instead of asking the ungrates to go back where they came from. I suppose you can't do that now as the Malays themselves are leaving. Actually the number of people who have migrated is likely to be much larger since not everybody registers with the embassy overseas.
Before you go overboard criticising the Penang government, know that the Penang state pays RM3billion in taxes to the federal govt and only gets RM100million in allocations. The federal govt has stalled on development in Penang such as the outer ring road and the monorail. There is virtually no investment in local infrastructure by the federal government. Since the time of Mahathir, power has increasingly been concentrated federally, so there is really no one to blame but BN for failing to develop Penang and failing to develop our education system and most outrageously, for the wanton wastage that has gone to enriching people like Razak Baginda and Khir Toyo instead of being used for proper development. Look at yourself first before criticising others...
written by James, December 01, 2009
I am an electronics engineer and was earning about RM5K/month. I was transferred to the US on an L1 visa, and was earning USD5K/month.
What can I get for RM5K in Malaysia? To own a Toyota Altis in Malaysia will cost me 60 months of my pay. In the US, it only costs me 3 months pay.
I had to return to Malaysia when my visa expired and my project completed. But given a second chance, I will definitely move to the US with my family. Half of my ex-classmates are all living and working in Australia, US, and Singapore, and very happy there. They are engineers, lawyers, architects, accountants. Probably more to follow.
Malaysia used to be a good place to live but not anymore. Crime rate, corruption, blatant racism (you can never advertise property in the US and give 10% discount to a particular race. You will be sued till your pants drop!), one-sided police force .... are all spoiling my beautiful country.
written by susie, December 01, 2009
written by pat ling, December 01, 2009
written by hermani, December 01, 2009
written by JQ, December 01, 2009
written by Binatang Nasional, December 01, 2009
written by Alan Goh, December 01, 2009
Do you think that the Govt.under UMNO control is worried or bothered
with the high migration of professionals overseas.The brain drain is
to their advantage otherwise,how can their Ketuanan Melayu continue
to take root in the country.PM Najib talk about the Malaysian Diaspora
and encouraging these Malaysians to return home to contribute to their
country of birth..I say to him Poorah..with the NEP,AP.Quota system,
flipflop education system and above all,corruption at all levels of Govt.
Dept.which saw Malaysia Global Corruption Index shooting up to 56
from 47,whereas Singapore stood as the World 3rd least corrupted
country,all these thanks to our past PM,Tun Mahathir,Tun Abdullah
Badawi and now PM Najib..
written by idiot-proof, December 01, 2009
written by Joker, December 01, 2009
Kohilan also pointed out that the government is taking some steps to attract talent to the country, including making it easier for foreigners with desired expertise to obtain permanent residence.
Kohilan, who is from Gerakan, also criticised the Penang state government currently under Pakatan Rakyat, saying that they should stop using the shortage of engineers an excuse for the recent loss of an RM10 billion electronic factory investment and should instead find ways to overcome it.
This clown minister knows his fact or not. Who rule penang for the last more than 25 years. He thinks engineer can be groom in within a short time where PR only rule from March 2008 tilll now. So Gerakan deserve to be kick off as the goverment of the day as they did nothing to groom "human capital" for the future of the country especially penang. At last the minister itself vomit out and informing PR to find the solution for the shortage. Well done Gerakan for all the years sitting and not thinking about the future of the people.
Now I know why many are migrating to find job elsewhere. Anyway BN should be happy as those migrate are frustrated people who usually vote for the opposition.Maybe one of the plan to get rid of Opposition voter - maybe yeh;
written by BKS, December 01, 2009
Afterall, I owe nothing to Malaysia apart from the fact that it was my birthplace and a place I grew up. Never received anything from the government, not even schooling. Whilst I've great love for the Malaysian people whom I regard as my people but the government of the day is alienating us the Pendatangs. You know the details.
I hold a Malaysian IC and Passport like any other Malaysians and that is about it because I do not have equal rights to participate fairly in my country.
Ahmad, Arumugam and myself could be standing side by side together singing Negaraku but Arumugam and me will never get into a public university, civil service or buy a property by merit and ability.
I love my countrymen but my country doesn't love me enshrined in letters.
written by Bigone, December 01, 2009
written by chris, December 01, 2009
No new investment that create more competetive jobs.
i myself take big risk to work abroad & to be honest it really pay off.
written by AP, December 01, 2009
written by Dangerous Variable, December 01, 2009
I thought it was almost all Malaysians that moved abroad are professionals letting their skills build another country with great rewards.
I do love my countrymen and my country but not those in power, politics and in government. The latter ought to go to hell.
written by ckh, December 01, 2009
written by GVK, December 01, 2009
written by Flight of the bumble bee, December 01, 2009
News about how our southern neighbor happily issues PR to professional Malaysians who were passed over for promotion because of race plus the news reports about the difficulty in getting Malaysia PR by professionals with foreign spouses justly reveals how sincere our Malaysian gomen wants professionals to return home. Many Indonesians are able to get the PR without problem compared to applicants with professional qualifications.
Like all other Malaysian gomen initiatives, its just talk only because the gomen are happy if the non-Malays migrate so that they can have 1 Malaysia all to themselves.
written by eagleis, December 01, 2009
written by sean, December 01, 2009
written by Netizen, December 01, 2009
It's easy to say that the government is taking steps to attract these Malaysians back home, but what steps? How attractive are they? Not when you give PR to unskilled Indons like maids and laborers, and when foreign spouses of Malaysians who are professionals can't even work here, let alone being offered permanent residence.
The home minster has said that receiving citizenship and PR is a privilege, not a right. This means, they can give it to whoever they want to, not whoever is qualified for it.
So much for empty talk. And don't try to get political capital by taking the opportunity to criticise Penang. You know too well the reasons.
written by Dharmika, December 02, 2009
""Patriotism" is a dirty word", I still remember clearly what my USM lecturer told us 20 years ago....
written by 1malaysian, December 02, 2009
Thankful that Chinese and Indian limited by qupta in local uni bcos local unis have bad standard? Shouldnt it be the otherway round. Because of quota our local uni level of education is comparable to an ape training ground. My advise to you is to do more travelling and if not reading to observe what is happening around the world.
written by EthnicMalaysia , December 02, 2009
written by Middle Aged Man, December 02, 2009
written by Justin L, December 02, 2009
written by hungry jacks, December 02, 2009
Psychologists tell us that the people we despise most are those whom we see as a reflection of the worst parts of ourselves. Since the BN and UMNO government hate Israel and the Jews so much, they must see the worst parts of themselves in them.
So BN & UMNO, why are you Zionists fighting for the rights of the Palestinians whilst persecuting your 'Palestinians' ? Something to ponder over heh.
written by Hang Jebat, December 02, 2009
written by yearofsnake, December 02, 2009
written by End NEP for Msians to come back, December 02, 2009
written by bob, December 02, 2009
written by Hak Ka King, December 02, 2009
written by tony, December 02, 2009
written by ryan, December 02, 2009
written by Farah, December 02, 2009
In the UK, with 50 pounds I can buy myself food for nearly a month. RM50 can barely last me a week. And now they want to implement GST?
RM50,000 and what are my choices for a new car? 1.3L and below, on which it'll take me years to pay back the loan. In the UK, I wouldn't even NEED a car because they have reliable public transportation.
If it weren't for my grandparents, I wouldn't have even returned to this country. I am faced with nothing but disappointment and frustration.
Spend over 30,000 pounds on my education in hopes for a bright future back home and THIS is what I get? I am torn between the love for my country and my hatred for the government.
written by farha, December 02, 2009
this isn't just a brain-drain issue...i think ALL malaysians, irrespective of race/religion, are unhappy with political situation/issues about the law/enroaching islamisation/lack of civil liberty....the lot!
the govt should do a lot of soul searching about this, or more malaysians will consider migrating.
written by Justice Pao Chin, December 02, 2009
In the country, there were several hurdles that he has to cleared and that took him months when he was jobless. When finally allowed to work he was offered a ordinary MO in a Government hospital or be a lecturerer in one of the local university. He is a non Malay no Muslim.
He was pissed off & left. He did not even want to say bye bye.
written by AhLoke, December 02, 2009
written by katak, December 02, 2009
written by wandererAUS, December 02, 2009
msleepyhead;
By the time your prediction came to light, my friend, we are in the next generation, do they care two hoots about this tiny peninsular....perhaps by then, Malaysians will be like Indonesians having their daughters
working as maids overseas.
written by PH Chin, December 02, 2009
“These are educated Malays and they feel frustrated with the system of governance and they have a global frame of reference to make comparisons,” he said"
Why even the educated Malay are interested to migrate to Australia ? Is Australia better than Malaysia from perspective of a Malay ?
Perhaps the BN's NEP or 'affirmative actions' has failed ? It seemed that the NEP only benefited a small privilege group of Malay while the majority remained as status quo.
written by pari, December 02, 2009
My family and I have been victims of crime, and even while sleeping i am awakened at the slightest sound, as these robbers are so daring, they do not hesitate to harm anyone in their way. When I used to drive in the city I used to have heart aches, as I had little children (well they are not little anymore). Motorists had no qualms about cutting into people lanes, even though it means the driver slamming his emergency brakes to avoid accidents. The list goes on and on.
I am overseas educated, my parents worked hard for me to secure a good education, and they gave up some of their dreams for their kids to be able to have a better life. A lot of parents are in the same boat.
Well, I have to work hard in my new country, just like i used to do in Malaysia. I never broke laws (with exception of minor) and paid my taxes diligently,and I do that here too.
My new country treats me like a first class citize, and I feel that way too. But I dream of going back to my beloved country, but I think my dream is going to remain a dream
written by allankong, December 02, 2009
Perhaps that is win win situation
In time the Chinese are gone and the Indians as well
You can have the whole country to yourself
No more bumiputra this and bumiputra that
Even the nep can be abolished
written by Jonathan, December 02, 2009
written by semuanya OK kot, December 02, 2009
written by Nik, December 02, 2009
written by AdamRazak, December 02, 2009
That's very naive of you to assume that skin colour doesn't count. Wake up. Ask a Malaysian accountant how arduous a journey it is to make partner at a big four outside Malaysia for example. They will tell you that it ain't all about who can rattle off the FRS from the top of their head.
And no I've not been brainwashed at BTN. Never even been to one. But this I shall not elaborate, as the debate is neither about me nor BTN. It is about why increasingly more Malays migrate. In my previous comment, I merely expressed the general undertone felt by Malays working in local MNCs. Sometimes you don't like the picture, but there is no need to kill the messenger.
Lastly, you seem to have a vision of a utopian world where the ground is level for every man and his dog. Well, here's news for you - it will never be. Thus as a person gifted with the privilege of a brain, best if you expand your energy navigating the undulating terrains, rather than trying to change the world. Leave the hard part to the likes of Obama.
As someone said to me, "If you only have an oar, don't waste your energy trying to change the course of the Titanic".
written by msleepyhead, December 03, 2009
Point taken.
The phenomenon is actually no different to the reasons cited for internal migration. A lot of people left their hometowns - kampungs, small towns, rural areas, etc. for the same reasons, with most settling in KL.
So what happens to their hometown when the young decides not to go back to their home town to contribute and improve things there?
written by Teck Khong, December 03, 2009
Uniting everyone are feelings of frustration, despair and anger; add to that the deep nostalgia and unrequited love of those who have departed the Malaysian shores for the land of their infant nurture.
It would be interesting to have the views of enlightened Malays, as they are the ones to realise the folly of their misguided kinsmen, to take over the helm and to steer a different course for Malaysia.
Not just because of race but a simple fact of numbers.
Otherwise, further decline will continue inexorably until the nadir is reached.
written by Bob, December 03, 2009
I am now live in NZ, I feel safe, I am treated equally and with dignity.
written by Dan, December 03, 2009
So why waste your time in Malaysia if you are not Bumi. When other countries we get equal chance. In Malaysia. practically zero. e.g. Only a bumi company can be allowed to tender to participate in a putrajaya tender. But the problem is most of these bumi companies are like cowboy companies also rotten to the core. How to expect to work with them.
This country is rotting to its core, the point is, the situation is worsening.
written by atheist, December 29, 2009
Yet others hv sent off their kids abroad first while they remain here to liquidate, and then they will get the hell out of bodohland!
A few days ago, my colleague & I inspected a few foreign passports & work permits issued by Immigration to Pakistanis - they landed at KLIA, no jobs waiting for them. They walked around the Klang valley looking for odd jobs. They smelt so bad I think they haven't showered for weeks. Why flood the country with all these hard labourers with no skills? The country is rotting bad; personally, I think Malaysia is finished. You won't find out how bad until it is TOO LATE!




